[not confirmed] Bone Shield, bug

[Kurukuku777]

This skill takes 20% less damage from all sources. The shield begins with 3 charges, and each damaging attack consumes a charge.

The bug is: only the mele attacks consume a charge. The caster's attacks don't consume a charge. This is the bug.

Anyone know how to fix it?

Thanks

[breakwater]

Can you tell us the spellid?

[Lynx3d]

I *think* he's talking about 49222 (Death Knight ability), but looking at the proc flags i don't really see how that's possible, can anyone confirm the problem?

Note that the spell has a small internal cooldown, like the Shaman shields, so not *every* attack will remove a charge.

[tibbi]

Works fine for me with Spell_proc_event filled well, mangos rev 11368, try:

-- (49222) Bone Shield

DELETE FROM spell_proc_event WHERE entry = 49222;

INSERT INTO spell_proc_event VALUES

(49222, 0x00, 0x0F, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0x00000000, 0, 0, 4);

Taken from https://github.com/bwsrv/spell_proc_event/blob/master/014_mangos_spell_proc_event.sql

Charges should be consumed when the DK gets attacked, not when he attacks afaik.

[Lynx3d]

That doesn't make much sense, why would you make it proc only on DK spells?

And proc flags come from DBC either way actually...

[tibbi]

why only DK spells? As i check that query now its old, we have made some custom change on it. With procflag 131752 (what we have now) it proc on each direct attack that damages the DK. According to dbc flag 172712 bone shield procs also on being damaged by aoe, and received heal, which it shouldnt as far as I know.

[Kurukuku777]

No, only mele attacks; automatical and skills for example mutilate, or any mele skill consumes a charge form de Bone shield.

The bug is that a magical skill such as frostbolt doesn't consume a charge, it must consume a charge.

Is the talent/skill, 49222.

In wowhead, http://www.wowhead.com/spell=49222/escudo-oseo (cataclysm) the only diference is the number of charges (in WOTLK 3, Cataclysm 4). The rest is identical.

[Lynx3d]

Can't confirm problem, at least this spell (used by NPCs) removes charges as expected: http://www.wowhead.com/spell=38204

[Kurukuku777]

I don't know if Npc's skills removes charges, but I am sure that pj's magical skills/spells don't remove charges.

[Moura]

Shaman's Earth and Lightning shields share this problem: they aren't triggered by enemy players' spells, charges are only consumed when hit by melee physical attacks. On the other hand, Water Shield works correctly and charges are consumed when hit by harmful spells.

Mangos Version: 11100

Custom Patches: Kero99

Database Name and Version : ytdb

How it SHOULD work: Charges should be consumed when hit by enemy players' spells.

How it DOES work: Charges aren,t consumed when hit by enemy players' spells.

[VladimirMangos]

Shaman's Earth and Lightning shields share this problem: they aren't triggered by enemy players' spells, charges are only consumed when hit by melee physical attacks.

Checked (including original report) and not confirmed.

[Febro]

Bone Shield charge is removed only by direct spells and melee attacks.

(http://www.wowwiki.com/Bone_Shield) = "AoE's, DoT ticks, auras and bleeds do not consume bones."

Also, each Bone Shield charge should have 2 seconds internal cooldown.

(http://pwnwear.com/2010/02/08/bone-shield-has-2s-cooldown/)