[BUG] Mutilate

[dardennf]

Some tests with Mutilate on a NPC without armor (2626 AP, no poisons, no "Find Weakness" and no "Opportunity")

Without lethality :

31 Crits => 726 (Min) / 1126 (Med) / 1668 (Max)

In theory we should have with lethality(5/5) =>

944 / 1464 / 2168

In game With lethality :

32 Crits => 809 (Min) / 1345 (Med) / 1889 (Max)

So results vary but there is an increase between 10% and 20%, but we can think there is a little problem with this talent .

Sorry for my english.

[stealthfox]

Mutilate is only adding at most 150 weapon damage to mainhand and some of it gets blocked occasionally. Its a combination of issues.

[hershaw121]

Some tests with Mutilate on a NPC without armor (2626 AP, no poisons, no "Find Weakness" and no "Opportunity")

Without lethality :

31 Crits => 726 (Min) / 1126 (Med) / 1668 (Max)

In theory we should have with lethality(5/5) => (you give this talent a 60% crit bonus here)

944 / 1464 / 2168

In game With lethality :

32 Crits => 809 (Min) / 1345 (Med) / 1889 (Max)

So results vary but there is an increase between 10% and 20%, but we can think there is a little problem with this talent .

Sorry for my english.

Lethality is adding 30% crit bonus.

a normal hit is doing 100% damage,

a critical hit is doing 200% damage,

a critical hit with Lethality is doing 230% damage.

Since your crits without Lethality is doing 200%, the increase of 230% over 200% is in reality a 15% increase

calculation: (230/200)-1*100% = 15%

[dardennf]

Oh yeah, actually I made this : 2*1.30 = 2.60 .

Thank you ^^.

So I think Lethality works properly.

[DLeonHeart]

in our server we have tested every talent that modifies mutilate and each talent seems to work properly, I think mutilate damage problem is in an incorrect formula.

[herman1988]

Can anybody fix it? I'm so horny to play with muti! Other talent trees sux in pvp

[DLeonHeart]

Does it fix mutilate?

it will not only fix mutilate but rogue damage in general, the bigest reason rogues are nerfed in mangos is because poisons are nor applying from special attacks.

as it has been said before, if you had both daggers with wound poison, and mutilate were to apply both poisons from the attack it would be near 1k more damge.